Tissues
Paper towels
Hanging file folders

Tissues, tissues, and more tissues
Clorox wipes
Expo Markers
White Board cleaner and rags
Legal pads/notebooks
Pens
Staples

Facial Tissue (Kleenex)
Paper towels
Pencils
Small, medium, and large latex-free gloves
Plastic cups
Plastic disposable mini cups with lids

Social studies teachers have requested (ranked more or less in order) the following:

Tissues/ Kleenex
Paper towels
Expo Markers
Pencils
Band-Aids
Markers/ colored pencils
Microfiber Clothes
Whiteboard erasers
Hand sanitizer
Lined paper

Puzzles - 100 pieces
Board games - gently used
Baby wipes
Baby oil
Kleenex
Uno cards
Paper towels
3 mil thermal laminating pouches
5 mil thermal laminating pouches
Velcro circles
White cardstock
Rollaway bed (twin) with sheets

General Fine Arts

Post-it Notes
Paper clips
Paper Towels
Hand sanitizer
Jugs of Ajax dish soap
Tissues
Dry erase markers

Visual Arts:

Newspapers
Tupperware containers
Dress forms / Mannequins
Working film SLR cameras
Frames with glass inserts (9x12+ size
Old Geographic books with vintage imagery
Cabinet-grade plywood scraps
Working hair dryers
Aluminum foil
Baby food/applesauce pouch twist-off caps
Gelato containers (Talenti, other hard plastic canisters with twist tops)
Clean yogurt cups
Gladware/lunchmeat containers/Tupperware with fitting lids
Mason jars with clean lids
Interesting glass bottles (no wine or soda bottles; empty and dry)
Clean styrofoam egg cartons
Eyeshadow and make-up pigment palettes (to make paints-can be used/expired)
Baby oil
Children's art supplies to repurpose (dried water-based markers, colored pencils, crayons, etc.)
Patio furniture for our courtyard
Box fans
Working power tools
Extension cords and power strips
Sewing machines, sewing notions, patterns, large fabric pieces

Color paper
Binder clips (small ones)
Pencils
Whiteout
Pop-up post-it notes
Color pencils
Index cards (blank / color)
Glue sticks
Expo Whiteboard cleaner
Red pens
File folders
Electric sharpener
Hole puncher for the classroom
Tape dispenser
Paper clips
Mounting tape
Hot glue gun and hot glue sticks
Color file folders
Color pocket folders 
Tissues 
Desk calendars 
Color index cards (lined)
Dry erase markers 
Acceptable cleaning supplies 
Sharpies
Permanent markers